How to Handle Workplace Bullying: A No-Nonsense Guide from Someone Who's Seen It All

Connect with us: SB Nation Sports Community | Evernote Professional Notes | Medium Articles | Professional Network | Community Discussions

I watched a grown man cry in a boardroom in Perth last month. Not because he'd lost a major client or stuffed up a presentation—because his manager had spent three years systematically destroying his confidence through workplace bullying. And honestly? I was furious. Not at him. At the system that let it happen.

Twenty-three years in corporate training and consulting, and I still see organisations pretending workplace bullying doesn't exist in their precious company culture. They've got fancy values statements plastered on walls while Brenda from accounts makes people's lives absolute hell every single day.

The Real Problem Nobody Wants to Talk About

Here's what drives me mental: most workplace bullying isn't the obvious stuff. It's not someone screaming or throwing things (though that happens too). It's the subtle, persistent undermining that HR departments struggle to pin down because it's "just personality conflicts" or "management style differences."

Rubbish.

When Sarah consistently excludes team members from meetings they should attend, that's bullying. When Dave takes credit for others' work while publicly criticising their contributions, that's bullying. When Jennifer uses her position to micromanage one specific employee while giving others complete autonomy—you guessed it.

The Australian Human Rights Commission found that 76% of workplace bullying involves psychological tactics rather than physical intimidation. But here's the kicker: only 23% of incidents ever get formally reported. Why? Because people are terrified of making it worse.

What Workplace Bullying Actually Looks Like

I've seen every variety of workplace bastardry you can imagine. The passive-aggressive email forwards. The deliberate exclusion from work social events. The impossible deadlines that somehow only apply to certain people. The constant questioning of competence in front of others.

And let's be brutally honest—sometimes it comes from the top. I once worked with a Melbourne tech startup where the CEO's "feedback style" was basically public humiliation disguised as "keeping standards high." Three talented developers quit in six months. The company folded within eighteen months.

But here's where I'll probably upset some people: not every difficult workplace interaction is bullying. Sometimes your boss is just demanding. Sometimes your colleague is having personal problems. Sometimes you're actually not performing well and need genuine feedback.

The difference? Intent, persistence, and power dynamics.

Real bullying involves repeated behaviour designed to intimidate, degrade, or control. It's systematic. It escalates. And it always involves some kind of power imbalance—whether that's hierarchical, social, or simply someone who knows how to work the system better.

The Bystander Problem (And Why Most People Are Useless)

Here's something that'll make you uncomfortable: if you've witnessed workplace bullying and done nothing, you're part of the problem.

I know, I know. "It's not my business." "I don't want to get involved." "What if I make it worse?"

But silence is complicity. Every time someone watches toxic behaviour and does nothing, they're sending a message that it's acceptable. They're teaching the bully that their actions have no consequences and showing the victim they're on their own.

Look, I get it. Speaking up is scary. Especially when the bully has more organisational power than you do. But there are ways to support colleagues without putting your own job at risk. Document what you see. Offer emotional support. Help them understand their options. Sometimes just knowing someone else recognises what's happening makes all the difference.

I once had a client—let's call him Mark—who was being systematically excluded from team communications by his supervisor. For months, he questioned whether he was imagining things. Then a colleague started copying him on emails he should have received and casually mentioning meetings he'd been left out of. Suddenly Mark realised he wasn't going crazy.

What Actually Works (Spoiler: It's Not What HR Tells You)

Most HR departments will tell you to "address it directly with the person" first. Sometimes that's good advice. Often it's completely useless.

If someone's bullying behaviour is calculated and persistent, a polite conversation isn't going to fix anything. In fact, it might make things worse by alerting them that you're onto their game.

Instead, here's what actually works:

Document everything. Dates, times, witnesses, exact quotes where possible. I can't stress this enough—memory fades, but documentation doesn't. Use your personal email, not company systems.

Build alliances. Bullies rarely target just one person. Find others who've experienced similar treatment. There's strength in numbers, and patterns become undeniable when multiple people report similar experiences.

Understand your company's actual culture, not their stated values. Some organisations genuinely care about preventing bullying. Others just want problems to disappear quietly. Figure out which type you're dealing with before deciding your strategy.

Know your rights. In Australia, you've got legal protections under various acts depending on your state. Workplace bullying training programs can help you understand exactly what constitutes unlawful behaviour.

Consider external options. Fair Work Commission, unions, professional associations—sometimes external pressure is the only thing that gets organisations to act.

The Management Blind Spot

Here's something that frustrates me endlessly: managers who genuinely believe bullying doesn't happen in their teams because they've never seen it.

Of course you haven't seen it, Malcolm. Bullies aren't stupid. They don't perform their worst behaviour when the boss is watching.

I worked with one company where a team leader was beloved by senior management—charming, results-driven, always volunteering for extra projects. Behind closed doors, she was systematically undermining newer team members, stealing their ideas, and creating an atmosphere of constant anxiety.

It took eighteen months and four resignations before management finally started asking questions. Even then, their first instinct was to blame "cultural fit" rather than investigate the leadership style.

Smart bullies are expert at managing up while terrorising down. They know exactly how to present themselves to people who matter while making life miserable for those who don't.

The Cost Nobody Calculates

Every organisation worries about the bottom line, but most completely ignore the financial impact of workplace bullying. Staff turnover. Recruitment costs. Lost productivity. Increased sick leave. Decreased morale affecting entire teams.

I once calculated that a single toxic manager cost their company approximately $180,000 over two years through direct and indirect impacts. That's recruitment, training, lost productivity, and the ripple effect on team performance.

And that's just the measurable stuff. How do you calculate the cost of good employees becoming disengaged? Of talented people avoiding your company because word gets around? Of the psychological impact spreading beyond the workplace into people's personal lives?

When to Fight and When to Walk

Not every battle is worth fighting. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is recognise a toxic environment and get out before it destroys your confidence and career prospects.

I learned this the hard way early in my career. Spent two years trying to "fix" a workplace that was fundamentally broken from the top down. All I achieved was burnout and a serious dent in my self-esteem.

But here's the thing—if you're in a position to make a stand, if you've got the documentation and support, if the organisation has shown any genuine commitment to cultural change—sometimes fighting is worth it.

Not just for you, but for everyone who comes after you.

The Real Solution (And Why Most Companies Get It Wrong)

Most workplace bullying policies focus on reactive measures—what to do after bullying has been reported. That's like installing smoke alarms but never checking for fire hazards.

Real prevention starts with organisational culture training that addresses power dynamics, communication styles, and accountability structures. It means hiring managers based on leadership capabilities, not just technical skills.

It means creating systems where employees can raise concerns without fear of retaliation. Where witnesses feel safe speaking up. Where there are genuine consequences for toxic behaviour, regardless of someone's position or performance in other areas.

Most importantly, it means acknowledging that workplace bullying is a leadership problem, not an individual personality problem.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Recovery

Even when bullying stops, the impact doesn't just disappear. I've worked with people years after leaving toxic workplaces who still second-guess every decision, who struggle with imposter syndrome, who find it difficult to trust new colleagues.

That's the real crime of workplace bullying—it doesn't just affect job performance, it affects how people see themselves and their capabilities.

Recovery takes time. It takes conscious effort to rebuild confidence. Sometimes it takes professional support to work through the psychological impact.

But here's what I've learned from watching dozens of people work through this process: resilience isn't about bouncing back to who you were before. It's about becoming someone stronger, someone who recognises toxic behaviour faster and has better boundaries.

What Needs to Change

We need to stop treating workplace bullying as an inevitable part of corporate life. We need leaders who understand that creating psychologically safe workplaces isn't just nice-to-have, it's essential for sustainable business success.

We need HR departments with actual teeth, not just policies that look good on paper. We need professional development programs that teach emotional intelligence alongside technical skills.

Most of all, we need to stop protecting toxic high performers and start recognising that no individual contribution is worth poisoning an entire team.

The grown man crying in that Perth boardroom? He's now thriving in a new role where his contributions are valued and his ideas are heard. The toxic manager? Still there, still making people miserable, still being protected because they "get results."

And that, frankly, tells you everything you need to know about why this problem persists.

Bottom line: Workplace bullying thrives in silence and dies in sunlight. The more we talk about it, document it, and refuse to accept it as normal, the less power it has.

Time to start talking.